# What to charge for a *message*, and when to raise it

If people already DM you for advice, a reply or a chat, you can price it. Start at *$5, $10 and $15 by length*, with an open price above that. That's Hotly's default, and Bailey Schildbach's page uses it. For advice, *price your time*, and raise your price when your inbox fills.

By Saloni Girhepuje - Updated November 20, 2026

## Real prices, and what each one is

Most advice on this is written for a different kind of creator, or gives a range with no source. These numbers come from platforms' own pages. They aren't the same product, so read the last column.

| Where | What fans pay for | The number | What it is |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hotly's default | A note, by length | $5 for a few lines (250 characters), $10 for a paragraph (500), $15 for a full letter (1,000), $16+ with no limit | Where every page starts, and you can change all of it. Bailey Schildbach's page uses these prices |
| Substack | A newsletter | $5 a month | Its minimum today, and its most common price in 8 of its top 10 categories in 2021 |
| Patreon | A membership | $5, $10 and $15 a month | The starting ladder Patreon suggests, not an average |
| Topmate | A written question | INR 500 to INR 10,000 | The range Topmate says creators charge for its Priority DMs |
| Clarity | A 30-minute call | About $50 | The average Clarity states for its experts. |

Substack, Patreon, Topmate and Clarity details checked November 2026: [Bailey Schildbach's page](https://www.hotly.com/schildba/penpal), [Substack's minimum price](https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/360037459952-How-do-I-set-up-a-paid-publication-on-Substack), [Substack on common prices (2021)](https://on.substack.com/p/grow-5), [Patreon on tiers](https://creatorhub.patreon.com/articles/how-to-structure-your-membership-and-price-your-benefits), [Patreon on raising prices](https://www.patreon.com/PatreonforCreators/posts/thinking-about-160037150), [Topmate Priority DMs](https://topmate.io/features/priority-dm), [Clarity for experts](https://clarity.fm/expert).

## Start by pricing length

- **Three prices, by how much fans can say.** Hotly is premium conversations: fans pay your price to write to you, for one note or every week. Every page starts at $5 for a few lines, $10 for a paragraph and $15 for a full letter, and fans who want more can pay $16 or up with no character limit. You can change all of it, from $1 up.
- **Length is a fair stand-in for your time.** A longer note takes longer to read and answer, and fans can see why it costs more.
- **What happened on one real page.** Bailey Schildbach's page uses these prices. On her page, $5 was the most common pick: a low first price lets more fans start.
- **Leave the top open.** Fans can pay any amount above your top price, with no character limit. On Bailey's page, a few fans who paid well above $15 made a real difference.
- **Read it as one creator.** Bailey has 500K+ followers on Instagram, so your mix will differ. Bailey is a Hotly creator and part of our referral program.

## Then adjust for who's writing

- **Why a note costs more than a newsletter.** Substack's most common price was $5 a month in 8 of its top 10 categories in 2021, and Patreon suggests starting at $5. A newsletter goes to everyone at once. A reply goes to one person and takes your time, so it can sit higher.
- **Fans saying thanks.** Stay close to the default. Fans usually pay $5-$20 weekly, and you can go higher or lower.
- **People asking for advice.** Price your time, not the length. Take what an hour of your time sells for and how long a good answer takes: 15 minutes at $100 an hour is $25. For scale, Clarity says its average 30-minute call is about $50, and Topmate says creators charge INR 500 to INR 10,000 for a written question.
- **Brands pitching you.** They want something from you for their business, so this can sit well above a fan note.
- **Fans who mostly want your content.** A paid note may be the wrong product. A $5 membership on a site like Patreon can suit them better.

## One note or every week

- **Offer both.** On Bailey's page, one-off notes and weekly fans both brought in a real share of the money.
- **One note pays more each time.** Fans buying one note often pick a longer one or an open price, so it tends to be bigger than a weekly payment.
- **Weekly fans come back.** On Bailey's page, fans who went weekly paid many more times than fans who only bought single notes.
- **A weekly price has a limit built in.** A weekly fan can write up to 2,000 characters a week, so one fan can't swallow your inbox.

## How many fans each price takes

Say you want to keep $500 a month from weekly fans. Counting the monthly price and about 4.33 weeks in a month, here's how many it takes.

- **$5 a week.** 30 fans on Hosted, 27 on Hosted Plus.
- **$10 a week.** 15 on Hosted, 14 on Hosted Plus.
- **$15 a week.** 10 on Hosted, 9 on Hosted Plus.
- **$20 a week.** 8 on Hosted, 7 on Hosted Plus.
- **$50 a week.** 3 on either plan.
- **That's the sum, not a forecast.** It assumes every fan pays every week. So keep telling your audience, more than once.

## When to change your price

- **Raise it when your inbox fills.** If you can't keep up with what's coming in, your price is too low.
- **Small rises tend to hold, at least on Patreon.** Patreon says several hundred creators who raised tier prices by $1 to $3 saw no significant drop in new members, and the typical one earned 10% more over the next six months. That's Patreon's own analysis, and it's about memberships, not messages.
- **Lower it if nobody writes.** Tell your audience more than once first. A link nobody has heard about isn't a pricing problem.
- **Fans already paying weekly stay put.** You change prices in your dashboard settings. A weekly fan keeps the price they signed up at, and your new prices apply to everyone else.

## What you keep at any price

- **The share doesn't move with the price.** You keep 80% on Hosted ($5.99 a month) and 90% on Hosted Plus ($9.99 a month), whether a note is $5 or $500. That pays for Stripe's card fees, hosting and upkeep.
- **Fans pay your price.** Nothing is added on top.
- **Invite creators and it drops.** The commission halves for every 5 creators you invite who join and pay, down to 5%.
- **Getting paid.** Your share is paid out once a month through Stripe to your bank, with no payout fee, from $1.
- **It isn't the lowest fee you can find.** A plain Stripe link keeps more per payment, with all the admin that comes with it. [Our Instagram guide](https://www.hotly.com/blog/charge-for-dms-on-instagram) has the numbers.

## Questions

**How much should I charge for a message?**
Start at $5, $10 and $15 by length, with an open price above that. That's Hotly's default, and Bailey Schildbach's page uses it. For advice, price your time instead.

**Is $5 too low?**
Not as your shortest option, if longer notes cost more and the top stays open. On Bailey's page, $5 was the most common pick, and fans who wanted to say more paid more. For advice it's usually too low, because a good answer takes time.

**Should I charge per message or weekly?**
Offer both if you can. One note pays more each time, and weekly fans keep coming back. On Hotly, fans choose on your page, and a weekly fan can write up to 2,000 characters a week.

**Can I raise my price later?**
Yes, in your dashboard settings. Fans already paying weekly stay on the price they signed up at. Patreon says creators who raised tier prices by $1 to $3 saw no significant drop in new members, though that's its own analysis of memberships.

**What do I keep at each price?**
The same share at any price: 80% on Hosted ($5.99 a month) or 90% on Hosted Plus ($9.99 a month). Stripe's fees are on us, and fans pay your price with nothing on top. The commission halves for every 5 creators you invite who join and pay, down to 5%.

---

**Start:** https://www.hotly.com/onboarding?plan=hosted_plus&from=guide-what-to-charge-for-a-message