Compare Popcall

Hotly vs Popcall

Which is better for paid DMs, Popcall or Hotly?

For pay-per-message DMs and on-demand video calls, Popcall: fans pay for each message, only if you reply within 2 days, and for each minute of a call, and Popcall can answer new Instagram DMs with your link. It keeps 20% after card fees and pays out monthly by PayPal, Zelle or ACH. For an ongoing conversation, Hotly: people pay $5–$20 weekly to write to you, or the price you set, you reply from one inbox on your own time, and Stripe's card fees are included. On $1,000 a month in $10 payments you keep about $753 on Popcall, $794 on Hotly Hosted and $890 on Hosted Plus. Popcall has no monthly fee, so below about $70 a month it keeps you more than Hosted Plus.

Start free for 30 daysCard at checkout, $0 until day 31, cancel in one click.

Updated

What a paid message looks like

  • $250 / week
    “Two offers. One pays more, one I'd actually learn at. Which would you take?”
    To a career coach · from Dani
  • $10 / week
    “What you said in Portland about starting over - I wrote it on my hand.”
    To a songwriter · from Priya

Side by side

FeatureHotlyPopcall
What people pay forA conversation with youEach message they send, and each minute of a video call
Paid messagesYes - the core product. People pay $5–$20 weekly, or the price you set.Fans pay your price for each message, only if you reply within 2 days (Popcall's terms say 3). Longer messages cost a multiple of your price.
Platform feeHosted: $5.99/mo + 20% commission, or $9.99/mo + 10% commission - servers, updates and backups included. Stripe's fees are on us. Invite five creators and the cut halves, down to 5%. Self-hosting the free code has 0% commission - you run it on your own server.No monthly fee. Popcall keeps 20%, and pays you 80% of what's left after card processing fees and sales tax.
You keep from $1,000 a month (100 payments of $10)$890 on Hosted Plus, $794 on Hosted. $940 on Hosted Plus once 5 creators you invite join and pay. Stripe's fees are on us.About $753: 80% of what's left after card fees, at Stripe's standard US rate. Popcall doesn't publish its processing rate.
What fans pay on topNothing on top. Fans pay your price; Stripe's card fees come out of our cut.Sales tax where Popcall must collect it. A hold goes on the fan's card first: usually about $20 for messages, and 30 minutes' worth for a call.
PayoutsStripe, to your bank. No payout fee, from $1.Monthly, by PayPal, Zelle or ACH, or PayPal or Wise outside the US. Bank and currency fees are yours.
Open sourceYes. Apache 2.0 License - take the code with you anytime.No public code
SignupPick a hosted plan, add a card - 30 days free - and set up your page in minutes. Or run the code on your own Linux server.Open: claim a username and set your rate. Not available in India, North Macedonia or the UAE.

Popcall details checked November 2026: Popcall, How Popcall charges for messages, Popcall reply window, How Popcall charges for calls, Popcall terms (May 2026 copy). Prices change - check before you switch.

Which one fits you

Pick Popcall if…

  • You want fans to pay for each message, with a 2-day reply window.
  • You want on-demand video calls, billed by the minute.
  • You want new Instagram DMs answered with your paid link automatically.

Pick Hotly if…

  • People want to keep talking to you week after week.
  • You'd rather reply on your own time than inside a 2-day window.
  • You want payouts through Stripe to your bank, from $1.
  • You want Stripe's card fees covered, and a commission that drops to 5% as creators you invite join and pay.

See your Hotly page before you switch.

Send us the link to your Popcall page. Within two days we'll email you a preview of your Hotly page, with your name, photo and prices, and the words to copy in. It's free, there's no sign-up, and your Popcall page keeps running.

Email us your linkOr write to care@hotly.com with the subject “Move me to Hotly: Popcall”
Bailey's page. Yours, with your name.

Questions

Is Hotly a Popcall alternative?
For paid messages, yes. Popcall charges for each message and each call minute; Hotly sells an ongoing conversation. People pay $5–$20 weekly to write to you, or the price you set.
Which takes a smaller cut?
Popcall keeps 20%, and pays its 80% after card fees. From $1,000 a month in $10 payments, Popcall leaves about $753 at Stripe's standard US rate. Hotly Hosted leaves $794 and Hosted Plus $890, with Stripe's fees included, and $940 once 5 creators you invite join and pay. Popcall has no monthly fee, so below about $70 a month it keeps you more than Hosted Plus.
Can I use Popcall and Hotly together?
Yes. Keep Popcall for on-demand calls, and add a Hotly link for people who want to keep writing to you.

Reply on your own time, not within 48 hours.

30 days free with a card at checkout. Hosted Plus is $9.99 a month plus 10%, which covers Stripe's card fees, hosting and upkeep. Invite five creators and the cut halves, down to 5%.

Card at checkout, $0 until day 31, cancel in one click. Open source: Get the code on GitHub anytime.