01
Nine platforms, side by side
Each platform's details are from its own site, help pages or terms. They're in order of how closely each fits the question: written answers first, then calls, then platforms where messages are one feature among many.
We make Hotly, so weigh that. Every other platform's details are from its own pages.
| Platform | What people pay for | What you keep | Monthly fee | What the asker pays on top | Getting paid |
|---|
| Brillay | A private question with up to two follow-ups, answered in writing | 92% on questions, less card processing | None | Nothing | Through Stripe to your bank, in 41 countries |
|---|
| DialMe | A paid DM from Instagram or X, a message pack, or a call by the minute | 80%, card processing included | None | Nothing | Through Stripe after a 7-day hold, from $10 |
|---|
| Hotly | A note at your price, once or every week, or a 30-minute video call | 90% on Hosted Plus, 80% on Hosted, Stripe's fees included | $9.99 or $5.99 | Nothing | Through Stripe to your bank, in 46 countries |
|---|
| Minnect | A question answered by text, video response or call | 80%, processing included | None | Not stated | Its terms aim for within 30 days of payment |
|---|
| Topmate | Calls, Priority DMs and other services | 90% from your own link, 80% from its marketplace, less a transaction charge | None | A platform fee by price, up to 5 in their currency or ₹10 | Within 7 business days of asking, for international payouts |
|---|
| Intro | A 1:1 video call, 15 minutes to 3 hours | 90% on bookings you bring, 70% from its marketplace | None | Not stated | Through Stripe or PayPal; its pages and terms differ on how |
|---|
| Passes | Memberships, paid messages, tips, livestreams and more | Up to 80% on Creators+, the plan every creator starts on, after processing | Not stated | A transaction fee may be added | From $50, or pay 6.5% or 10% to be paid faster |
|---|
| Fanfix | Memberships, paid DMs and locked content, with prices or minimums Fanfix sets | 80% | None to join | 13% on credit cards | Weekly, per its FAQ |
|---|
| Buy Me a Coffee | A tip, with an optional message | 95%, less Stripe's fees; supporters can cover the card fee | None | The card fee, only if you pass it on | From $10; the first payout can take 7 to 14 days |
|---|
Sources: Brillay, Brillay pricing, Brillay: how it works, Brillay: payouts, Brillay terms, DialMe, DialMe FAQ, DialMe terms, DialMe guidelines, Minnect, Minnect for experts, Minnect terms, Topmate fees, Topmate refund policy, Topmate payout guidelines, Topmate: add your services, Topmate: Priority DMs, Intro for experts, Intro FAQ, Intro terms, What is Passes, Passes Creators+ plan, Passes terms, Passes payouts, Passes fan payments, Passes community guidelines, Fanfix FAQ, Fanfix creator terms, Fanfix payment terms, Buy Me a Coffee FAQ, Buy Me a Coffee: charges on a payment, Buy Me a Coffee: payouts, Buy Me a Coffee: how it works. Terms change - check them before you decide.
02
Pick by how you like to answer
Written answers, on your own time: Brillay, DialMe, Hotly and Minnect. Nobody books a slot, and you reply when you can.
Calls: Topmate and Intro are built around booked calls. DialMe, Hotly and Minnect add calls to messages.
Messages as one feature among many: Passes and Fanfix are membership platforms where paid messages sit next to posts. Buy Me a Coffee takes tips with a note, not paid questions.
Then compare what you keep. A lower cut with card fees on your side can keep you less than a higher cut without them, and a monthly fee matters most in a quiet month.
03
Brillay: best for one-off paid questions
How it works. A follower pays upfront to ask one private question, with up to two follow-ups, and you answer in writing inside a reply window you set, "anything from a few hours to five days". The same link can sell custom work, personalized videos, tips and goals. If you decline a request, "or it goes unanswered in time, the follower's payment is returned."
Who it's for. Creators whose followers already ask them for things. "There is no follower minimum, no application and nothing to qualify for", and creators must be 18 or older. It has "no marketplace roster", so new askers come from your own link.
What you keep. Brillay keeps 8% on paid questions, custom work and videos, and 5% on tips and goals, with no monthly fee. Card processing comes out of your earnings on top. At Stripe's US rate of 2.9% plus 30 cents, which Brillay's own payouts page cites, you keep about 86% of a $10 question.
Getting paid. Through Stripe to a local bank. Creators in 41 countries can get paid, and Stripe sets the payout schedule. A new account's first payout is scheduled within 7 to 14 days of its first payment.
Pick something else if you want followers to pay every week rather than once, or you'd rather not pay card fees from your share.
04
DialMe: best for charging for your Instagram and X DMs
How it works. Connect Instagram or X and set a price per message. DialMe replies to new DMs with a payment link, either all of them or only those with your trigger words. You answer from DialMe's inbox, "and your replies go back to the original chat." You can also sell message packs and private calls by the minute, and free first messages are optional.
Who it's for. In its own words, "creators, coaches, experts, advisors, founders". "You don't need a huge following", and NSFW content isn't allowed. To connect Instagram you need a creator or business account; you can also share a dialme.com link instead.
What you keep. DialMe takes 20% of paid messages, packs and calls, and its terms say Stripe's fees "are included within that 20% and are borne by DialMe". There's no monthly subscription.
Getting paid. Earnings are held for 7 days. Then you press a payout button to send them to your Stripe account, from $10.
Calls. Paid by the minute, recorded for safety and deleted after 45 days. A call you don't start within 72 hours is refunded.
Pick something else if you want followers to subscribe and keep writing, or you'd rather keep more than 80% as you grow.
05
Hotly: best for ongoing conversations
How it works. Hotly is premium conversations for creators, coaches and experts. You share one link, and people pay $5–$20 weekly to write to you, or the price you set: one note at a time, or every week. You reply from one inbox when it suits you.
Calls too. Followers can also book a 30-minute, one-to-one video call on your own Zoom account, currently $250. You offer two call times a week, on the day you already reply. If you cancel or can't make it, the follower gets a full refund. More in paid calls with Zoom.
Who it's for. Anyone whose audience already writes to them with questions, brand pitches or thank-yous. There's no follower minimum and no application. Bailey Schildbach, who has 536K followers on Instagram, banked $22,400 in her first 60 days, brand deals included: read her story.
What you keep. On Hosted Plus you pay $9.99 a month and keep 90% of what followers pay. On Hosted you pay $5.99 a month and keep 80%. Stripe's fees are included, and followers pay your price with nothing added. The commission halves for every 5 creators you invite who join and pay, down to 5%. Both plans start with 30 days free.
Getting paid. Stripe pays out to your bank, in 46 countries. The code is open source under the Apache 2.0 License, so you can also run it on your own server with 0% commission.
Pick something else if you want no monthly fee: Brillay, DialMe, Minnect, Topmate and Intro cost nothing in a quiet month. At $10 questions, Brillay keeps you more than Hosted Plus until about $250 a month, and more than Hosted at any amount. Hotly's calls have a set length and price, while Topmate and Intro let you choose both. And Hotly works with the followers you have rather than finding you new ones.
06
Minnect: best for answering by text, video or call in one app
How it works. Askers choose how they want an answer: "Text message, phone call, video call, or video response." You set the rate for each format. Minnect tells askers "You are only charged when an expert responds". Its terms say payment is collected when the order is placed, "unless we indicate otherwise at checkout".
Who it's for. Experts. You sign up, tap Become an Expert, fill in a short questionnaire about your background, and wait for approval. Askers find you in its app, which says it's available in 200+ countries.
What you keep. 80%. Its terms set the fee at "twenty percent (20%) of the Transaction Amount" and say Minnect pays the processing fees. It costs $0 to join.
Getting paid. Its page for experts says "Get paid after every response." Its terms add a holding period, and say Minnect will try to pay you "no later than thirty (30) days" from when the asker paid.
Know before you start. Its terms ban using AI "to craft responses or answers".
Pick something else if you only want written questions: Brillay leaves you more of each one.
07
Topmate: best for selling calls and DMs from one page
How it works. A page of services: 1:1 calls, Priority DMs, digital products, packages and webinars. For a Priority DM you set a price and a time frame to reply in. Its refund policy says it will normally refund the buyer when there's no "substantive response" in that window.
Who it's for. Coaches and experts who sell more than one kind of service from one page, in rupees or other currencies. There's no monthly plan and no fee to sign up.
What you keep. Topmate takes 10% of a sale through your own page or link, and 20% when a new buyer finds you through its marketplace or search. A transaction charge comes off too: its fees page says at least 2% in rupees and 3% to 6% in other currencies, and its payout guidelines add that "The minimum transaction fee is $1." GST is charged on Topmate's fee, not on your price.
What buyers pay. Your price plus a platform fee set by price band: up to 5 in dollars, pounds or euros, or ₹10 in rupees. As its fees page puts it, "a $40 session carries a $3 fee".
Getting paid. Your first payout can be requested 7 days after your first paid booking. International payouts are processed within 7 business days of asking, with no fee from 10 in your currency.
Pick something else if you'd rather askers paid only your price, with nothing added. More in how to get paid to answer questions.
08
Intro: best for credentialed experts selling video calls
How it works. Askers book a 1:1 video call at your price, from 15 minutes to 3 hours, and it goes in your calendar. Calls have a timer, so they don't run over. It's built for calls, not written answers.
Who it's for. Experts with a track record. Intro calls itself an "Invite-only marketplace", and its terms say every expert has at least one credential in their category, verified by a third party or claimed.
What you keep. "Intro is free to join." It takes a 30% commission on bookings through its marketplace and 10% on bookings you bring yourself.
Getting paid. Its page for experts says "Connect your bank account & get automated payouts. Powered by Stripe & Intro." Its terms, last updated in 2022, say you request payment once you have more than $10, and Intro pays "via PayPal or Stripe, within 7 days".
Pick something else if you'd rather answer in writing, or you aren't ready to apply to a vetted marketplace.
09
Passes: best when messages are one of many things you sell
How it works. Buyers can pay for memberships, paid messages, tips, livestream access and shop items. Paid messages sit alongside locked content, livestreams and 1:1 calls.
Who it's for. Creators who want many ways to sell in one app. It's "a PG-13 platform that hosts minors", and its guidelines say "13–17 yo fans may not receive DMs".
What you keep. "Passes takes a 20% cut of your earnings on Creators+", and "All creators start on Creators+ by default." Its terms work out your share after "payment or transaction processing fees", so you keep up to 80%. A transaction fee "may be added at checkout" for buyers.
Getting paid. You need at least $50 in eligible earnings to request a payout. Payouts in 2 to 5 business days are free, or, where it's enabled, you can pay 6.5% for 1 business day or 10% for instant. Its terms say something else: by default, every two weeks, "within thirty (30) days" of the end of each period.
Pick something else if paid messages are the main thing you sell. More in how Passes works.
10
Fanfix: best for invite-only memberships with paid DMs
How it works. A subscription platform for members-only content, where buyers can also pay for direct messages and locked content. Fanfix sets membership prices and the minimum price for each DM, which you can ask to adjust.
Who it's for. It's invite-only: "every application is carefully reviewed", and you need active social media handles. It calls itself "a strictly safe-for-work (SFW) platform", for 18 and over.
What you keep. Creators receive 80%, and Fanfix keeps "the remaining 20% of every transaction", direct messages included. Buyers pay "a surcharge of 13% on all credit cards".
Getting paid. Its FAQ says earnings are processed every Wednesday and usually reach your bank on Friday. Its creator terms say about 30 days after the end of the month.
Pick something else if you want to set your own membership and message prices, or to promote other platforms from your account, which its creator terms bar. More in how Fanfix works.
11
Buy Me a Coffee: best for tips with a note, not paid answers
How it works. Supporters pay your coffee price, "the default is $5", or more, and they "can leave a message" with it. It has no paid-question feature, so a message comes with a tip, not as a question you're paid to answer. It also sells memberships and shop items.
Who it's for. "Anyone with an audience": YouTubers, musicians, podcasters, writers and more.
What you keep. "We charge a 5% transaction fee, and creators keep 95% of the earnings", with no monthly fee. Stripe charges 2.9% plus 30 cents a payment and 0.5% on payouts, and extra fees may apply: 1% on international payments and 0.5% on subscriptions. You choose whether supporters cover the card fee.
Getting paid. You can request a payout once your balance reaches $10. The first one can take 7 to 14 days, while your account is reviewed.
Pick something else if people want answers, not just a way to say thanks. More in creator platform fees.
12
How we checked this list
From each platform's own pages. Every detail is from the platform's own site, help pages or terms. Where they don't say something, the table says "Not stated".
We make Hotly. Hotly's details are from its own site: its pricing, facts and paid calls pages. Weigh that.
Fees change. If something here is out of date, write to care@hotly.com and we'll fix it.