Blog · Pricing

What to charge for a message, and when to raise it

If people already DM you for advice, a reply or a chat, you can price it. Start at $5, $10 and $15 by length, with an open price above that. That's Hotly's default, and Bailey Schildbach's page uses it. For advice, price your time, and raise your price when your inbox fills.

Start free for 30 daysCard at checkout, $0 until day 31, cancel in one click. Change plan on the next screen.

By Saloni Girhepuje · Updated

Real prices, and what each one is

Most advice on this is written for a different kind of creator, or gives a range with no source. These numbers come from platforms' own pages. They aren't the same product, so read the last column.

WhereWhat fans pay forThe numberWhat it is
Hotly's defaultA note, by length$5 for a few lines (250 characters), $10 for a paragraph (500), $15 for a full letter (1,000), $16+ with no limitWhere every page starts, and you can change all of it. Bailey Schildbach's page uses these prices
SubstackA newsletter$5 a monthIts minimum today, and its most common price in 8 of its top 10 categories in 2021
PatreonA membership$5, $10 and $15 a monthThe starting ladder Patreon suggests, not an average
TopmateA written question₹500 to ₹10,000The range Topmate says creators charge for its Priority DMs
ClarityA 30-minute callAbout $50The average Clarity states for its experts.

Sources: Bailey Schildbach's page, Substack's minimum price, Substack on common prices (2021), Patreon on tiers, Patreon on raising prices, Topmate Priority DMs, Clarity for experts. Terms change - check them before you decide.

Start by pricing length

  • Three prices, by how much fans can say. Hotly is premium conversations: fans pay your price to write to you, for one note or every week. Every page starts at $5 for a few lines, $10 for a paragraph and $15 for a full letter, and fans who want more can pay $16 or up with no character limit. You can change all of it, from $1 up.
  • Length is a fair stand-in for your time. A longer note takes longer to read and answer, and fans can see why it costs more.
  • What happened on one real page. Bailey Schildbach's page uses these prices. On her page, $5 was the most common pick: a low first price lets more fans start.
  • Leave the top open. Fans can pay any amount above your top price, with no character limit. On Bailey's page, a few fans who paid well above $15 made a real difference.
  • Read it as one creator. Bailey has 500K+ followers on Instagram, so your mix will differ. Bailey is a Hotly creator and part of our referral program.

Then adjust for who's writing

  • Why a note costs more than a newsletter. Substack's most common price was $5 a month in 8 of its top 10 categories in 2021, and Patreon suggests starting at $5. A newsletter goes to everyone at once. A reply goes to one person and takes your time, so it can sit higher.
  • Fans saying thanks. Stay close to the default. Fans usually pay $5–$20 weekly, and you can go higher or lower.
  • People asking for advice. Price your time, not the length. Take what an hour of your time sells for and how long a good answer takes: 15 minutes at $100 an hour is $25. For scale, Clarity says its average 30-minute call is about $50, and Topmate says creators charge ₹500 to ₹10,000 for a written question.
  • Brands pitching you. They want something from you for their business, so this can sit well above a fan note.
  • Fans who mostly want your content. A paid note may be the wrong product. A $5 membership on a site like Patreon can suit them better.

One note or every week

  • Offer both. On Bailey's page, one-off notes and weekly fans both brought in a real share of the money.
  • One note pays more each time. Fans buying one note often pick a longer one or an open price, so it tends to be bigger than a weekly payment.
  • Weekly fans come back. On Bailey's page, fans who went weekly paid many more times than fans who only bought single notes.
  • A weekly price has a limit built in. A weekly fan can write up to 2,000 characters a week, so one fan can't swallow your inbox.

How many fans each price takes

Say you want to keep $500 a month from weekly fans. Counting the monthly price and about 4.33 weeks in a month, here's how many it takes.

  • $5 a week. 30 fans on Hosted, 27 on Hosted Plus.
  • $10 a week. 15 on Hosted, 14 on Hosted Plus.
  • $15 a week. 10 on Hosted, 9 on Hosted Plus.
  • $20 a week. 8 on Hosted, 7 on Hosted Plus.
  • $50 a week. 3 on either plan.
  • That's the sum, not a forecast. It assumes every fan pays every week. So keep telling your audience, more than once.

When to change your price

  • Raise it when your inbox fills. If you can't keep up with what's coming in, your price is too low.
  • Small rises tend to hold, at least on Patreon. Patreon says several hundred creators who raised tier prices by $1 to $3 saw no significant drop in new members, and the typical one earned 10% more over the next six months. That's Patreon's own analysis, and it's about memberships, not messages.
  • Lower it if nobody writes. Tell your audience more than once first. A link nobody has heard about isn't a pricing problem.
  • Fans already paying weekly stay put. You change prices in your dashboard settings. A weekly fan keeps the price they signed up at, and your new prices apply to everyone else.

What you keep at any price

  • The share doesn't move with the price. You keep 80% on Hosted ($5.99 a month) and 90% on Hosted Plus ($9.99 a month), whether a note is $5 or $500. That pays for Stripe's card fees, hosting and upkeep.
  • Fans pay your price. Nothing is added on top.
  • Invite creators and it drops. The commission halves for every 5 creators you invite who join and pay, down to 5%.
  • Getting paid. Your share is paid out once a month through Stripe to your bank, with no payout fee, from $1.
  • It isn't the lowest fee you can find. A plain Stripe link keeps more per payment, with all the admin that comes with it. Our Instagram guide has the numbers.

Questions

How much should I charge for a message?
Start at $5, $10 and $15 by length, with an open price above that. That's Hotly's default, and Bailey Schildbach's page uses it. For advice, price your time instead.
Is $5 too low?
Not as your shortest option, if longer notes cost more and the top stays open. On Bailey's page, $5 was the most common pick, and fans who wanted to say more paid more. For advice it's usually too low, because a good answer takes time.
Should I charge per message or weekly?
Offer both if you can. One note pays more each time, and weekly fans keep coming back. On Hotly, fans choose on your page, and a weekly fan can write up to 2,000 characters a week.
Can I raise my price later?
Yes, in your dashboard settings. Fans already paying weekly stay on the price they signed up at. Patreon says creators who raised tier prices by $1 to $3 saw no significant drop in new members, though that's its own analysis of memberships.
What do I keep at each price?
The same share at any price: 80% on Hosted ($5.99 a month) or 90% on Hosted Plus ($9.99 a month). Stripe's fees are on us, and fans pay your price with nothing on top. The commission halves for every 5 creators you invite who join and pay, down to 5%.

Set your price. Change it when you need to.

30 days free with a card at checkout. You set the price, fans pay nothing on top, and the code is open source.

Start free for 30 days

Card at checkout, $0 until day 31, cancel in one click. Change plan on the next screen.