01
What you keep from one $50 reading, ten ways
Here's one reading at $50.00, close to the $48.18 and $50.00 email readings on Etsy below. On Keen, Kasamba and Purple Garden it's 10 minutes at $4.99 a minute, the middle price of the 18 readers on Keen's tarot page: $49.90.
Each platform's fees are from its own pages, with two exceptions. Fiverr's 20% is from Wise and ConductAtlas. Popcall doesn't publish its card processing, so we used Stripe's US rate.
We make Hotly, so weigh that. Every other platform's figures are from the pages listed under the table.
| Selling on | The client pays | You keep | How it's worked out |
|---|
| Hotly Hosted Plus | $50.00 | $45.00, and the plan is $9.99 a month | 10% commission ($5.00), Stripe's card fees included |
|---|
| Hotly Hosted | $50.00 | $40.00, and the plan is $5.99 a month | 20% commission ($10.00), Stripe's card fees included |
|---|
| Etsy | $50.00 | $44.80 | $0.20 to list, 6.5% of the sale ($3.25) and 3% + 25¢ card processing ($1.75) |
|---|
| Etsy, when an Offsite Ad made the sale | $50.00 | $37.30 | The same, plus 15% ($7.50). Bigger shops pay 12% |
|---|
| Brillay | $50.00 | $44.25 | 8% ($4.00), plus Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ from your share ($1.75) |
|---|
| Fiverr | $50.00 | $40.00 | 20% ($10.00) |
|---|
| Popcall | $50.00 | $38.60 | Card processing first ($1.75 at Stripe's US rate), then 20% of the rest ($9.65) |
|---|
| Keen | $49.90 (10 minutes at $4.99) | $21.11 | $0.40 a minute ($4.00) first, then Keen keeps 54% of the rest |
|---|
| Kasamba, by chat | $49.90 (10 minutes at $4.99) | $17.94 | $0.39 a minute ($3.90) first, then Kasamba keeps 61% of the rest |
|---|
| Purple Garden, by chat | $49.90 (10 minutes at $4.99) | $17.28 | $0.19 a minute ($1.90) first, then Purple Garden keeps 64% of the rest |
|---|
Sources: Etsy search, "email tarot reading", Etsy: Tarot Reading by Email, Etsy: Detailed Psychic Tarot Reading by Email, Etsy: Three Question Tarot Reading, Etsy: 15-minute video reading, Etsy: live reading by WhatsApp, Stan Store: same-day love reading, Etsy fees, Etsy help: card processing, Etsy Services policy, Keen tarot readers, Keen earnings calculation, Kasamba advisor terms, Purple Garden advisor terms, Flowdara tarot pricing guide, Brillay tarot pricing guide, Brillay pricing, Brillay payouts, Wise on Fiverr fees, ConductAtlas on Fiverr's 20%, Popcall, Popcall terms (May 2026 copy), Stripe restricted businesses, Tarot Association UK note, Ofcom psychic TV guidance. Terms change - check them before you decide.
02
What 58 Etsy listings charge for an email reading
A low middle, and a long tail. Etsy's first results page for "email tarot reading", in US dollars, had 58 listings, 23 of them ads. They ran from $0.62 to $152.03. A quarter cost less than $3.48, the middle one was $7.96, and a quarter cost more than $22.63.
Many were marked down. 38 of the 58 showed a crossed-out "original" price, 35 promised same-hour or fast delivery, and 9 said "No AI".
Single listings. A "Tarot Reading by Email" was $50.00, a "Detailed Psychic Tarot Reading by Email" $48.18, and a three-question reading sent as an audio link by email $65.00. A 15-minute video reading was $26.25, on sale from $35, and one reader sold a live reading by WhatsApp, text or phone for $37.46.
Off Etsy. On Stan Store, one reader sells a same-day love reading, a PDF letter sent by email within 24 hours, for $88.
03
What live and per-minute readings cost
Live readings. Flowdara's pricing guide, updated in October 2026, says 30 minutes "usually costs $40 to $75", and 60 minutes $75 to $150.
By the spread. Brillay's guide suggests $10 to $20 for one card, $25 to $50 for three, and $60 to $120 or more for a Celtic Cross.
By the minute. The 18 readers on Keen's tarot page charged $1.99 to $11.11 a minute, with a middle of $4.99. Ten minutes at that rate is $49.90, about what the $48.18 and $50.00 email readings above cost. What the apps keep of it is in what readers keep on Keen, Kasamba and Purple Garden.
04
How to set your own price
- Start from your time. Count how long a reading takes you to pull, write up and send. If it's about half an hour, the live price for 30 minutes, $40 to $75, is a fair guide.
- Price by the spread. A one-card pull, three cards and a Celtic Cross take different amounts of time, so they can cost different amounts, as on Brillay's ladder above.
- $7.96 isn't your price. It's the middle of one crowded search page, where 38 of 58 listings were marked down. Clients who come to you through your own following aren't choosing from that page.
- Give regulars a weekly price. Clients who come back every week can pay one weekly price instead of buying each reading.
05
Rules that shape a reading for sale
Etsy sells the reading, not the service. Its Services policy, last updated 9 June 2026, says "In general, services are not allowed to be sold on Etsy." Readings are allowed as something you deliver: "Tarot, psychic, or other divination readings must include a tangible good, such as photos of the tarot spread, audio/video of a reading, or text of the reading. The tangible good may be delivered through Etsy Messages or email."
Describe the reading, not what it will bring. Stripe takes card payments for Hotly, Brillay and many other shops, and its list of banned businesses includes "Businesses that make outrageous claims, use deceptive testimonials, use high-pressure upselling or use fake testimonials". Say what the client gets: the spread, the length, when you reply.
In the UK, sources differ. The Tarot Association's UK note says nothing requires a "for entertainment only" line, while Ofcom requires one for psychic services on TV (both). We haven't settled it, so check what applies to you.
06
Where Hotly fits
Hotly is premium conversations. A client pays your price to write to you with their question, and you reply with the reading on the day you pick. You price by how much they write: every page starts at $5, $10 and $15, with an open price from $16, and you can change all of it, from $1 up. Clients pay by card on the web, through Stripe.
Regulars can go weekly. A weekly price lets a client write to you every week, up to 2,000 characters, and they keep the price they signed up at.
What it costs. On Hosted Plus you pay $9.99 a month and keep 90% of what clients pay. On Hosted you pay $5.99 a month and keep 80%. Stripe's card fees are included, and clients pay your price with nothing added. The commission halves for every 5 creators you invite who join and pay, down to 5%. Your share is paid out once a month through Stripe to your bank, with no payout fee, from $1.
Where the others win. Etsy and the per-minute apps bring you buyers who are already searching. Hotly has no marketplace, so clients come from your own following. On fees alone, Etsy and Brillay leave you a little more than Hosted Plus, because they have no monthly price: at ten $50 readings a month, Etsy leaves $448, Brillay $443 and Hosted Plus $440. Hotly suits readers whose followers already ask them for readings. 30 days free if you want to try it.
Why the monthly price can still be worth it. You pay $9.99 a month for three things Etsy doesn't give you. Your page shows only you, not a search page where $3.48 and $22.63 readings sit next to yours. A regular can pay one weekly price and keep writing, instead of buying a new listing each time. And no sale ever pays Etsy's 15% Offsite Ads fee: if 2 of every ten sales came through an Etsy ad, Hotly would leave you more.